New York New York Pizza

Reviews

• Sammi L.

  star star star star star 19 January 2021

  Even though the guys thought I was crazy for ordering a BBQ, Chicken, Bacon, Ranch, Honey pie, when they made this beautiful pie they couldn't help but say "well it does smell great!"
  
  super delicious and thankful for the love they put into this one. Thanks gents!!

• Peter N.

  star star star star star_border 13 January 2021

  We've had New York New York on a couple of occasions now. One big reason we like this place are the variety of non pizza options they have just in case someone doesn't feel like pizza when everyone else wants it.
  
  With that said, our go to is the cheese pizza. Not too much sauce, thin enough crust to give that nice bite/crunch. Very well done and my kid loves it.
  
  I also tried the lamb gyro. Not the best and not the worst. It needed a bit more flavor/seasoning. And while I love feta cheese, the blocks of feta maybe overkill..chomping it up a little more would be preferable and easier to eat.
  
  Dare I say it.. the garlic knots were just too garlicky. I get it; if you order garlic knots, be prepared for garlic. And I love garlic; the minced garlic is great but the amount that's out on almost seems like your eating spoon of garlic with a touch of bread-- I think a little less garlic and these things would be great.
  
  Overall, awesome pizza, good food and can't wait to try some more stuff in the future!

• Andy D.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 10 January 2021

  So here's how my pizza showed up. Hmmm, worst pizza to date and severely undercooked. I've had pizza from the place many times, but this one makes me want to look elsewhere.

• Amanda H.

  star star star star star_border 6 January 2021

  Wow! What a fantastic little pizza shop! I have driven past this place so many times and wanted to try it. Well, tonight we finally turned the car in. This place was so busy. Pizzas were just flying out the door. (That is a great sign.) this kids eat ordered a slice of cheese pizza. I had the white pizza slice, and hubby got the meat lovers slice. 4 slices of pizza and two drinks came out to about $14. Not too bad! Then they delivered the four slices of heaven to our table. The crust was perfectly cooked with a nice crust yet a little chew. The taste was on point. I loved my white pizza. The kids inhaled their cheese pizza slices with huge smiles. The hubby was impressed. He said it was the best pizza he has had since we moved to the area 12 years ago. The kids were so happy as it reminded them of the pizza in New York. That is a huge compliment. We are already planning our next trip back.

• Rick K.

  star star star star star 4 January 2021

  Amazing pizza from New York. It has been while since I had true NY slice. Growing up in NY I remover the smell and taste and the minute I took bite of this I went back in times almost 30 years. Wow. If you want NY style pizza then this is the place. Keep up the good work.